Pragmatism or bold innovation: what really separates the businesses that scale?
Scaling a business is never straightforward. As the ScaleUp Challenge Report shows, only 4% of UK businesses ever break through the barrier of 10 employees and move into true scaleup territory. The real question is: what separates those who do from those who don’t?
On ScaleUp Radio this week, Granger and I had two conversations that highlight just how differently founders can approach the same challenge. One is pragmatic, disciplined, and focused on cash and resilience. The other is bold, experimental, and driven by vision and innovation.
Let’s look at the lessons from Andy Western of AJW Solutions and Sam Boards and Matias Carpio of Onlyscience and ask which approach is closer to your own.
Resilience vs. Innovation: Two Very Different Starting Points
Andy Western was forced into entrepreneurship when a management buyout collapsed. From there he built AJW Solutions supplying the MOD within six months, and later founded Sam Boards, creating sensory products for neurodiversity and dementia. His story is about resilience, pragmatism, and adapting to external shocks such as COVID halting his tactile products and personal setbacks that pushed him to refocus.
Matias Carpio walked away from a PhD because academia felt too risk averse. With Onlyscience, he is trying to democratise data science for marketing with a plug and play SaaS tool built from scratch with his own code. His story is about bold innovation, pushing ideas that others avoid, and rethinking what is possible in data driven marketing.
Both show courage, but they channel it very differently.
Cash Discipline or Experimentation: Which Really Builds Value?
Andy is laser focused on cash. He knows “profit is sanity, turnover is vanity” and insists on pro forma payments even from giants like Rolls Royce. He has built Sam Boards by reinvesting profits from AJW Solutions, refusing to overextend until the product has proven traction.
Matias, meanwhile, embraces experimentation. He bootstrapped his first year using free tools and personal coding, then shifted to raising investment when the product needed to scale. He even A/B tests his investor pitches, a data led mindset that mirrors his product’s mission.
The ScaleUp Challenge Report backs both perspectives. Nearly half of businesses admit they would “suffer a lot” if the owner stepped away for three months. Cash flow discipline and repeatable systems keep a business alive, but bold experimentation is often the spark that unlocks new markets.
The Power of Listening to Your Users
Both Andy and Matias built their products through relentless feedback loops.
Andy 3D printed prototypes, left them with schools and dementia centres, and made crucial design changes based on what users told him.
Matias worked closely with 6 to 8 agencies, ensuring Onlyscience solved their real problems and spoke their language.
This mirrors what I talk about in The Entrepreneurial ScaleUp System. Growth comes from solving a genuine customer problem in a way that is scalable, not from guessing.
What About You?
So here is the killer question: Are you too cautious to ever scale your business?
If you lean towards Andy’s approach, you may need to challenge yourself to embrace bolder experimentation. If you relate more to Matias, you may need to ground your vision with financial discipline and repeatable systems.
The truth is that the businesses that scale sustainably balance both. They have the resilience to withstand setbacks and the vision to seize opportunities.
Prefer a Quick Breakdown?
In this week’s ScaleUp Radio Shorts, Granger Forson and I unpack the biggest lessons from Andy and Matias, comparing pragmatism with innovation in scaling.
“Cash flow discipline keeps you alive. Innovation is what helps you grow.” – Kevin Brent
“Vision without systems is chaos, but systems without vision just keep you small.” – Granger Forson
👉 Watch the Shorts episode here
Final Thoughts
The ScaleUp Challenge Report tells us that 61% of business owners expect to double in size over the next three years, yet only 19% actually do. The gap is not in desire, it is in execution and mindset.
Andy and Matias prove there is no single formula. But there is a consistent truth: if you stay stuck in caution, you will never scale.
Take the Next Step
Share this post: